# Article: Modular Cleanroom vs Conventional Cleanroom Construction: Which Is Better for Your Indonesia Project?

## Brief Introduction
When planning a cleanroom project in Indonesia, choosing the right construction method is just as important as deciding on the required ISO classification. Some manufacturers prefer conventional on-si

## Main Content


When planning a cleanroom project in Indonesia, choosing the right construction method is just as important as deciding on the required ISO classification. Some manufacturers prefer conventional on-site construction, while others choose modular cleanroom systems to reduce construction time and make future expansion easier.

Both approaches can deliver controlled environments that meet the required cleanroom standards. However, their construction processes, costs, installation requirements and long-term flexibility are quite different.



For manufacturers operating in Indonesia, these differences deserve careful consideration. Local weather conditions, industrial building layouts, labour availability and future business plans can all influence which solution makes more sense.1. Conventional Cleanroom Construction: Built Directly on Site

Conventional cleanrooms are constructed as part of the building itself. Walls, ceilings, partitions and other structural elements are installed on site, with HVAC ducts, electrical services and other utilities integrated into the building structure.

This approach has been widely used for large, permanent facilities, including pharmaceutical plants, food processing factories and other manufacturing facilities where cleanroom areas are closely integrated with the main building.

However, construction can become complicated when several contractors are involved.

For example, wall preparation, ceiling installation, HVAC ductwork, electrical services and cleanroom panel sealing often need to be completed in a specific sequence. If one contractor falls behind, the next team may have to wait. Problems can also occur when service openings, duct connections or equipment positions do not match the original design.

These issues are not unique to Indonesia, but local site conditions can make them more difficult to manage.

Construction Challenges in Indonesia

Indonesia&#39;s rainy season can affect several stages of conventional construction. Masonry, plastering, waterproofing and material handling may be delayed when work areas are exposed to heavy rain or high humidity.

For projects in Java, Sumatra and other regions with extended rainy periods, these interruptions can affect the overall construction schedule.

There are also practical differences between industrial sites. Some factories have limited space for material storage, while others operate within existing production buildings where construction activities must be coordinated around ongoing operations.

Another challenge is the coordination between civil contractors, MEP contractors and cleanroom specialists. If the building structure is not properly prepared, cleanroom installation may require additional sealing, surface correction or modifications to existing service connections.

For a project with a fixed production launch date, these delays can become a serious concern.2. Modular Cleanroom Systems: More Work Prepared Before Installation

Modular cleanroom systems use prefabricated components that are manufactured before they arrive at the project site.

Depending on the system design, these components may include:

Cleanroom wall panels and ceiling panels

Aluminium profiles and connection systems

FFU (Fan Filter Unit) frames and installation provisions

Doors, windows and viewing panels

Sealing profiles and accessories

Prefabricated openings for electrical and mechanical services

Because many components are prepared in advance, the amount of work required on site can be reduced.

Instead of building every wall and ceiling from the beginning, the installation team assembles the prefabricated components according to the approved cleanroom layout.

This does not eliminate the need for site preparation or engineering coordination. The building structure, floor conditions, HVAC connections, electrical supplies and other utilities still need to be properly planned.

However, moving part of the work from the construction site to a controlled manufacturing environment can make installation more predictable.

Why Modular Systems Can Work Well in Indonesia

For projects in Indonesia, one practical advantage is reduced exposure to weather-related construction delays.

Although transportation and site installation can still be affected by heavy rain, prefabricated panels and other components can be manufactured and prepared before the main installation work begins.

This allows some activities to proceed in parallel rather than waiting for every stage of conventional civil construction to be completed.

Modular systems can be particularly useful for:

Small and medium-sized pharmaceutical production areas

Cosmetic and personal care manufacturing facilities

Food and beverage processing environments

Medical device manufacturing workshops

Research laboratories and pilot production facilities

Additional cleanroom areas inside existing factories

For manufacturers operating in leased industrial buildings, modular construction also offers another advantage: suitable components may be dismantled and reused if the business moves to another facility.

The feasibility of relocation depends on the condition of the components, the original installation method and the compatibility of the new site.3. Modular vs Conventional Cleanroom Construction: Key Differences

The right comparison should consider the entire project, rather than looking only at the price of construction materials.ComparisonModular CleanroomConventional ConstructionConstruction methodPrefabricated components assembled on siteMore work carried out directly on siteInitial material costGenerally higherPotentially lowerOn-site labourGenerally less intensiveOften more labour-intensiveInstallation scheduleOften shorter and more predictableMore dependent on construction sequenceWeather exposureReduced for prefabricated workGreater exposure during site constructionFuture expansionUsually easier to modifyMay require structural alterationsLayout changesSuitable panels can be reconfiguredOften involves demolition and reconstructionRelocationPossible for suitable modular systemsGenerally difficultLarge integrated facilitiesDepends on system designOften suitable for permanent integrated structures

These are general comparisons, not fixed rules. The actual result depends on project size, design complexity, local material availability, site conditions and the scope of work.4. Initial Construction Cost vs Total Project Cost

One common misunderstanding is that modular cleanrooms are always more expensive.

In terms of initial material costs, modular systems generally require a higher investment in prefabricated panels, profiles and integrated components than basic conventional building materials.

However, the initial construction price does not tell the whole story.

A proper cost comparison should also consider:

Site labour and supervision

Conventional construction may require more labour-intensive activities and longer coordination between different contractors. Modular installation can reduce some of these requirements.

Rework and construction delays

Poor coordination, incorrect openings, surface defects and weather-related interruptions can increase the cost of conventional projects. Prefabrication can help reduce certain site-related risks, provided the design and measurements are accurate.

Future modifications

If production requirements change, modular panels may be easier to remove, replace or rearrange. Conventional structures are generally more difficult to modify.

Time before production starts

An earlier project completion date may allow a manufacturer to begin production sooner. This can be commercially important, particularly when the facility is being developed to support a new product or production line.

For this reason, manufacturers should compare the total project cost and expected operating benefits, rather than choosing a construction method based only on the initial quotation.5. Which Solution Makes More Sense for Indonesian Manufacturing Facilities?

Indonesia&#39;s manufacturing environment includes a wide range of industrial buildings, from newly developed factory campuses to leased production units in established industrial estates.

The most suitable cleanroom construction method depends largely on the type of facility and the company&#39;s future plans.When Modular Cleanroom Systems Are Worth Considering

A modular system may be a good choice when:

The project has a tight construction schedule.

The cleanroom will be installed inside an existing factory building.

The company operates in a leased industrial property.

Future expansion or layout changes are expected.

Site construction space is limited.

Reducing on-site civil work is a priority.

For example, a manufacturer setting up a new cosmetic production area inside an existing industrial building may prefer a modular system because it can simplify installation and make future adjustments easier.

Similarly, companies planning additional ISO Class 7 or ISO Class 8 production areas may benefit from a modular layout, depending on the process requirements.When Conventional Construction May Be the Better Option

Conventional construction can still be the more practical solution for certain projects.

It may be preferable when:

The cleanroom is part of a large, permanent factory development.

The facility requires extensive structural integration.

Heavy process equipment, drainage systems and fixed utilities are closely connected to the building structure.

The cleanroom layout is unlikely to change significantly.

The project requires architectural or structural features that are difficult to achieve with a standard modular system.

For a large pharmaceutical manufacturing campus, for example, conventional construction may provide a more integrated approach to the overall building and utility infrastructure.

Modular components can still be incorporated into parts of the facility where they offer practical advantages.

In other words, these two approaches do not always have to be mutually exclusive. A hybrid solution may be appropriate for projects with different construction requirements across different areas.

6. What Should You Check Before Choosing a Cleanroom Construction Method?

Before deciding between modular and conventional construction, manufacturers should review several technical and commercial factors.

1. Production requirements

Start with the manufacturing process. Required cleanliness levels, personnel activities, equipment arrangements and material flows will influence the cleanroom layout.

2. HVAC and environmental control

The HVAC system must be designed around the required air cleanliness, temperature, humidity, air changes and pressure differentials. A modular wall and ceiling system alone cannot guarantee the required environmental conditions.

3. Existing building conditions

Check floor levels, structural capacity, ceiling height, available service routes and existing electrical and mechanical infrastructure before finalising the design.

4. Future production plans

Consider whether the company may introduce new products, increase capacity or reorganise production areas over the next few years.

5. Qualification and regulatory requirements

For pharmaceutical projects in Indonesia, the applicable CPOB requirements must be considered from the design stage. Cleanroom classification under ISO 14644 is important, but it does not by itself demonstrate full GMP or CPOB compliance.

The facility must also address relevant requirements for personnel, equipment, production processes, documentation, qualification and validation.

These considerations should be included in the initial project planning rather than treated as additional tasks after construction is completed.7. Choosing the Right Cleanroom Solution for Your Project

There is no single construction method that works best for every cleanroom project.

Modular cleanroom systems are worth considering when installation speed, reduced site work and future flexibility are important. Conventional construction may be more appropriate for large, permanent facilities that require extensive integration with the main building structure.

For many Indonesian manufacturers, the decision comes down to understanding the actual production requirements, available building conditions and expected business changes.

At PT Ocean Purification Indonesia, we help clients evaluate cleanroom construction options based on their facility requirements and project conditions.

From cleanroom layout planning and modular panel systems to HVAC integration and installation, our focus is on developing practical solutions that support reliable manufacturing operations.

Planning a new cleanroom or upgrading an existing facility in Indonesia?

Contact PT Ocean Purification Indonesia to discuss your project requirements and explore the right cleanroom construction approach for your facility.
